1958 Varsity Football Roster
| No. | Name | Position | Height | Weight | Year |
| 10 | John Blake | QB | 5’7″ | 145 | So. |
| 11 | Ashley Scarborough | QB | 5’6″ | 150 | Sr. |
| 12 | Robert Mott | QB | 5’10” | 153 | Jr. |
| 22 | Michael Hefferman | RHB | 5’8″ | 152 | Sr. |
| 25 | John Sokal | LHB | 5’7″ | 155 | Sr. |
| 30 | John Matricciani | FB | 5’8″ | 158 | Jr. |
| 31 | Robert Harner | FB | 5’9″ | 160 | So. |
| 33 | Joseph Sergi | FB | 5’7″ | 156 | Jr. |
| 40 | Thomas Truss | RHB | 5’7″ | 154 | Sr. |
| 41 | Dominic Motto | RHB | 5’7″ | 152 | Jr. |
| 43 | Parker McCourt | RHB | 5’6″ | 155 | Jr. |
| 44 | Robert Weininger | FB | 6’0″ | 165 | Jr. |
| 50 | Louis Bury | C | 6’0″ | 178 | Jr. |
| 52 | Stanley Marshall | C | 5’7″ | 150 | Jr. |
| 55 | John Stolins | C | 5’8″ | 182 | Sr. |
| 60 | Michael Bittner | G | 5’4″ | 155 | So. |
| 61 | Robert Johnson | LHB | 5’11” | 158 | So. |
| 62 | Raphael Giudice | G | 5’5″ | 167 | Sr. |
| 63 | James Keelty | G | 5’11” | 190 | Jr. |
| 64 | David Blake | E | 5’8″ | 158 | Sr. |
| 65 | Robert Krastel | G | 5’6″ | 172 | Sr. |
| 66 | William Heidel | G | 5’4″ | 145 | So. |
| 70 | Melvin Ernst | T | 6’0″ | 173 | Jr. |
| 71 | William Lathroum | T | 6’1″ | 240 | Jr. |
| 72 | Joseph Dell’Acqua | G | 5’7″ | 190 | Jr. |
| 73 | Frank Culotta | T | 5’9″ | 195 | Sr. |
| 74 | James Smerowski | T | 5’11” | 171 | So. |
| 76 | Edward McNamara | T | 5’10” | 202 | Jr. |
| 79 | Eugene Nuth | T | 6’2″ | 165 | Jr. |
| 80 | Joseph Nattans | E | 5’11” | 160 | Jr. |
| 81 | Robert Boddiford | E | 6’1″ | 155 | So. |
| 82 | Albert Grau | E | 6’1″ | 160 | Sr. |
| 83 | Maurice Fisher | E | 6’0″ | 170 | Sr. |
| 84 | Frederick McFaul | E | 6’2″ | 155 | So. |
| 85 | Leo Welsh | E | 6’0″ | 163 | Jr. |
| 87 | Donald Kent | E | 5’9″ | 170 | Sr. |
| Athletic Director: | Brother D. Andrew, F.S.C. |
| Ass’t Athletic Director: | Brother D. John, F.S.C. |
| Moderator: | Brother D. John, F.S.C. |
| Head Coach: | George B Young, Jr. |
| Assistant Coach: | Joseph Carroll |
| Trainer: | John Sanborne |